As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
The best countertop ice maker should match the ice you actually want and the amount you use at one time. A machine making hollow bullet ice for everyday drinks solves a different problem from a nugget maker bought for its texture. Neither a fast first batch nor a large daily output figure tells you how much ice will be waiting in the basket when guests arrive.
I compare six selected U.S.-market options covering everyday countertop ice, square cubes, and nugget ice. For straightforward bullet-ice use, I would start with the EUHOMY IM001-B. For nugget ice, I would compare the EUHOMY IM039 with the ecozy IM-NS451B, depending on whether simpler operation or app control matters more.
Editorial Note: This is a research-based comparison, not a hands-on test. I reviewed the selected listings, manufacturer information, and relevant instructions, and excluded unrelated products returned during research. Production and timing figures are published claims, not my measurements. I have not tested comparative noise, energy consumption, ice retention, or long-term reliability.
Key Takeaways
Choose the ice type first. The EUHOMY IM001-B and Silonn SLIM33B make bullet ice, while the Frigidaire offers two ice-size settings. The EUHOMY IM-FP makes square cubes. The IM039 and ecozy make nugget ice. These are different purchase choices, not interchangeable versions of one feature.
Daily production is not storage capacity. A 26-pound daily claim does not mean a machine holds 26 pounds. The IM001-B’s published basket capacity is 1.3 pounds; the IM-FP’s is 2.6 pounds. Plan to use or transfer ice as the basket fills.
Allow for refilling, cleaning, and freezer space. Removable parts and cleaning cycles can simplify ownership, but they do not eliminate care. Even ecozy’s insulated model comes with instructions to transfer finished ice to a freezer rather than rely on the basket for long-term storage.
Top Picks Summary
Everyday Bullet-Ice Pick — EUHOMY IM001-B. My starting choice for a compact, manually filled machine with a carry handle and cleaning cycle.
Simple-Control Alternative — Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK. A black countertop model with two ice-size settings, a viewing window, and water-level and ice-full indicators.
Expandable-Basket Pick — Silonn SLIM33B. Worth considering when basket access and an expanding collection area matter more than a different ice shape.
Square-Cube Pick — EUHOMY IM-FP / Tile Plus. The distinct choice here for square cubes, selectable thickness, and two advertised water-refill methods.
Compact Nugget-Ice Pick — EUHOMY IM039 / Pearl L1 Max. Nugget ice with a removable lid, dual-pump cleaning, and four cleaner packs in the described bundle.
App-Control Nugget Pick — ecozy IM-NS451B. A pull-out water tank and full-color interface, with app and voice control for buyers who will use them.
Countertop Ice Maker Comparison Table
The figures below describe the selected configurations. A first-ice claim, a batch time, and a daily maximum measure different things; they should not be treated as a single speed ranking.
| Product | Ice Type | Published Daily Output | Published Timing | Basket / Refill Setup | Included Accessories |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK | Small ice cubes; two sizes | Up to 26 lb/24 h | Nine pieces per 5–6-minute cycle, per selected listing | Up to 1.5-lb ice basket; 2.3-qt reservoir, per Curtis | Ice scoop and instructions |
| EUHOMY IM001-B | Bullet | Up to 26 lb/24 h | Nine pieces in six minutes, advertised | 1.3-lb ice basket; manual refill; carry handle | Ice basket and scoop |
| Silonn SLIM33B | Bullet; two sizes | 22–26 lb/24 h, manufacturer specification | Nine pieces in six minutes, advertised | 2.5-L expandable basket; manual refill | Expandable ice basket and scoop |
| EUHOMY IM-FP / Tile Plus | Square cubes; selectable thickness | Up to 45 lb/24 h | 24 pieces in as little as 13 minutes; brand listing also gives 13–20 minutes | 2.6-lb ice basket; two advertised refill methods | Ice basket, scoop, and instructions |
| EUHOMY IM039 / Pearl L1 Max | Nugget | Up to 35 lb/24 h | First ice in about 5–7 minutes, per brand | About 1.8-lb / 800-g basket; 1.1-L water tank; manual refill | Ice basket, scoop, instructions, and four cleaner packs |
| ecozy IM-NS451B | Nugget | Up to 44 lb/24 h | Manual describes roughly 10-minute cycles; initial use can take longer | Removable ice basket; pull-out water tank | Pre-installed ice basket, scoop, user manual, and quick guide |
Product sources are linked below. Basket volumes in liters are not directly equivalent to pounds of loose ice. For Frigidaire, the capacities come from Curtis’s catalog entry with matching UPC; the cycle time is a selected-listing claim. Silonn’s listing advertises 26.5 lb/day, but the table uses the manufacturer’s 22–26 lb range. No common-condition test establishes which model fills a usable basket fastest. The ecozy accessory list follows its manual rather than counting listing-only extras as guaranteed equipment.
Product Reviews
Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK — Simple-Control Alternative
The black EFIC128AMZBLK is the Frigidaire I would compare when the priority is a straightforward countertop setup. Two ice-size settings and a viewing window are more relevant to that buyer than the connected controls on the ecozy. Its appeal is the basic serving routine: add water, select a size, and collect ice as it is made.
This section covers the selected black EFIC128AMZBLK listing. Amazon’s detailed fields identify EFIC128AMZBLACK and UPC 058465832094. The Curtis/Frigidaire catalog entry for EFIC128_AMZ-BLACK carries the same UPC. That provides a specific product match without borrowing a specification from EFIC117-SS or another similarly named version.
Curtis publishes a 2.3-quart water reservoir and storage for up to 1.5 pounds of ice, alongside the 26-pound daily-production claim. These describe three separate quantities. The reservoir determines the water initially available; the basket limits the ice collected at one time; the daily maximum describes repeated production, not a reserve waiting for guests.
The selected listing advertises nine pieces per five-to-six-minute cycle and indicators for adding water and emptying a full basket. I would treat the timing as a small-batch claim, not a reason to call this the fastest option. The listing also explicitly says the machine does not keep finished ice frozen, so plan to serve it or transfer it to a freezer.
My reason to consider it is simple operation with stated reservoir and basket capacities. I would favor the EUHOMY IM001-B when its documented carry handle and cleaning cycle are the features I need most. An automatic cleaning program is not established by the exact Frigidaire sources used here; that is a limitation of the evidence, not proof that every EFIC128 variant lacks one. The scoop and instructions are listed, while cleaners and freezer containers should be planned separately.
Reasons to Buy
- Two ice-size settings and a viewing window.
- Water-level and ice-full indicators.
- Published reservoir and basket capacities help with refill and serving planning.
Reasons to Avoid
- The basket is not a freezer; unused ice needs transferring.
- Buyers specifically seeking an automatic cleaning cycle should confirm that feature for this exact version.
EUHOMY IM001-B — Everyday Bullet-Ice Pick
The IM001-B is my starting pick for someone who wants a conventional countertop ice maker without adding smart controls or switching to nugget ice. The combination I find useful is a carry handle, removable basket, included scoop, and advertised cleaning cycle. Those are practical differences you interact with each time you set up or empty the machine.
The selected black IM001-B listing advertises nine bullet-shaped pieces in six minutes and up to 26 pounds in 24 hours. Its brand comparison chart gives a 1.3-pound basket. That six-minute headline describes a small batch, not a promise that the basket is full or that enough ice for a party is immediately available.
The listing gives dimensions of 11.42 inches deep, 8.74 inches wide, and 11.57 inches high, with a weight of 12.9 pounds. Measure the intended counter position and leave the ventilation clearance required by the supplied instructions. The handle helps with moving the appliance, but “portable” should not be read as battery-powered or permission to use it in wet outdoor conditions.
When comparing this EUHOMY with the Frigidaire, the documented carry handle and cleaning cycle are the features I would weigh first. Against the Silonn, it keeps the purchase focused on a conventional basket rather than an expanding one. These are practical configuration differences; similarly worded short-cycle claims do not establish a meaningful speed advantage.
The limitation is serving quantity. Someone making a few drinks can keep returning to the basket; someone supplying several people together needs a reserve. For square cubes or nugget texture, choose the appropriate machine below rather than expect this bullet model to imitate them.
Reasons to Buy
- Carry handle and a compact published footprint.
- Cleaning cycle, basket, and scoop in the described configuration.
- A straightforward starting point for bullet-ice use.
Reasons to Avoid
- The 1.3-pound basket requires planning for larger servings.
- Does not provide square cubes or nugget ice.
Silonn SLIM33B — Expandable-Basket Pick
The SLIM33B gives this shortlist a useful alternative to another nearly identical bullet-ice machine. Its defining feature is the expanding basket. Silonn describes a spring-loaded arrangement that expands downward as ice accumulates, with a nominal 2.5-liter collection volume. That changes the way ice is collected rather than the type of ice being made.
The SLIM33B manufacturer page describes two bullet-ice sizes, LED touch controls, and self-cleaning. The selected expandable-basket listing advertises nine pieces in six minutes. These features suit a buyer who still wants conventional bullet ice but prefers a different collection setup.
The output claims need perspective. I use the manufacturer’s specification of 22–26 pounds per day here; the selected retail listing advertises 26.5 pounds. That difference is not a measured advantage over a 26-pound competitor. For my decision, the expandable basket is the meaningful distinction, rather than a small variation between published maximum-output figures.
The 2.5-liter number also cannot be compared directly with another maker’s basket rating in pounds. One is volume and the other is ice mass; neither proves the same amount of usable ice will remain available after sitting. I would buy for the basket’s access and layout, then manage serving and freezer transfers separately.
Choose another option when your real goal is nugget texture, square cubes, or app control. This Silonn remains a bullet-ice purchase. Its most convincing role is offering a different collection arrangement without asking you to buy a completely different category of ice maker.
Reasons to Buy
- 2.5-liter expandable basket differentiates the collection setup.
- Two bullet-ice sizes and LED touch controls.
- Advertised cleaning cycle and included scoop.
Reasons to Avoid
- Published daily-output figures differ between sources.
- Basket volume is not evidence of longer frozen storage.
EUHOMY IM-FP / Tile Plus — Square-Cube Pick
The IM-FP is the option I would examine first when square cubes are the point of the purchase. It changes the ice format rather than simply adding a larger output claim to the bullet machines. EUHOMY’s current product range calls this model Tile Plus; the selected listing also identifies part IM004-CSI.
The selected 45-pound listing advertises 24 pieces in as little as 13 minutes. EUHOMY’s ASIN-linked comparison chart also gives a 13–20-minute operating cycle and a 2.6-pound basket. That basket is larger by stated ice mass than the IM001-B’s 1.3-pound basket, but neither figure establishes a measured hourly serving rate.
The Tile Plus product page specifies selectable ice thickness and scheduled ice-making. Thickness control is the useful distinction for someone who wants to adjust the cube format rather than accept a single setting. Start with the setting that suits your drinks; do not assume the shortest advertised time describes every thickness.
Two water-refill methods are advertised, giving another point to check before purchasing. Verify the exact refill arrangement and compatible accessories in the offered package. I have not counted an external water container as included or treated refill flexibility as proof of a permanent plumbing connection.
Cleaning still needs attention. EUHOMY’s own product FAQ recommends weekly cleaning and wiping internal surfaces, despite the automatic-cleaning feature. I would choose this model for its cube format, thickness control, and basket arrangement—not for unsupported promises that it is quieter, cheaper to run, or more reliable than the smaller machines.
Reasons to Buy
- Square cubes with selectable thickness.
- Published 2.6-pound basket and up-to-45-pound daily output.
- Scheduled ice-making and two advertised refill methods.
Reasons to Avoid
- Batch timing varies; 13 minutes is not a universal result.
- Extra refill accessories should not be assumed to be included.
EUHOMY IM039 / Pearl L1 Max — Compact Nugget-Ice Pick
The IM039 is the nugget option I would start with when the ice itself matters more than app control. It is a different machine from the IM001-B, despite similar brand naming and overlapping product recommendations on retail pages. The selected grey listing identifies IM039 and the bundle with four cleaner packs.
EUHOMY markets it as the Pearl L1 Max, with up to 35 pounds per day and first nugget ice in approximately five to seven minutes. The brand lists a 1.1-liter water tank and an 800-gram ice basket, approximately the 1.8-pound rating used in its retail comparison chart. First ice is not a full basket.
The maintenance arrangement is a stronger buying reason than an isolated speed claim. A detachable lid gives access, while the advertised dual-pump cleaning system provides a cleaning cycle. The included cleaner packs also make the initial package more complete. None of that is a substitute for following the cleaning instructions or evidence of independently tested sanitation performance.
The selected listing gives dimensions of 11.14 inches deep, 8.5 inches wide, and 12.28 inches high. I would compare that footprint with the counter area available and consider how often a 1.1-liter manually filled tank fits the household routine. It is not an automatic water-line installation.
For a person deliberately buying nugget ice, this is a focused alternative to the more feature-heavy ecozy. The trade-off is ongoing refilling and ice handling. Choose ecozy when its pull-out tank and connected controls would genuinely help; choose a bullet model when nugget texture is not important enough to drive the purchase.
Reasons to Buy
- Nugget ice in a documented compact configuration.
- Detachable lid and advertised dual-pump cleaning.
- Four cleaner packs identified in the selected bundle.
Reasons to Avoid
- The 1.1-liter tank is manually refilled.
- A five-to-seven-minute start does not supply a full basket.
ecozy IM-NS451B — App-Control Nugget Pick
The ecozy is the model I would consider when refilling access and connected controls matter alongside nugget ice. Its appeal is not simply the advertised 44-pound daily output. The pull-out water tank and removable basket change everyday handling, while the full-color panel offers a different interface from the simpler machines.
The IM-NS451B manufacturer page describes EcozyHome app control, Alexa and Google Assistant support, a basket light, and temperature and TDS readouts. I would pay for those features only when they make the appliance easier to use. The display alone is not evidence that its ice is cleaner than another model’s.
Insulation needs a careful reading. Although ecozy promotes double-layer insulation, its own product page recommends promptly transferring ice to a freezer. The IM-NS451B manual also gives freezer-transfer instructions. This is a nugget maker with a collection basket, not a replacement for frozen storage.
The manual describes roughly 10-minute cycles, with longer initial operation possible. I would not compare that number directly with the IM039’s first-ice claim. The documents also contain differing dimensions; confirm the actual height and required clearance before choosing it for a tight under-cabinet space.
The core equipment counted in this comparison is the pre-installed ice basket, scoop, user manual, and quick guide shown in the manual. Ice bags appear in the selected retail listing, but I have not treated them as guaranteed extras across packages. My recommendation is for buyers who value the refill design and connected interface enough to use them; otherwise, the IM039 is the simpler nugget shortlist option.
Reasons to Buy
- Pull-out water tank and removable basket.
- App and voice control with a full-color display.
- Basket lighting and an advertised cleaning cycle.
Reasons to Avoid
- Insulation does not eliminate freezer transfers.
- Confirm dimensions and bundle extras rather than relying on one listing field.
How to Choose the Best Countertop Ice Maker
Decide which ice format is worth buying a machine for
Start with the drink and serving preference, not the largest number on the box. The IM001-B and SLIM33B are bullet-ice options, while Frigidaire offers two ice-size settings for everyday drinks. Nugget ice is the specific attraction of the IM039 and ecozy. The IM-FP is the square-cube alternative, with a thickness setting that adds a different adjustment.
A machine with a larger daily output is still the wrong purchase when it makes an ice shape you do not want. Equally, do not pay for a nugget model merely because it appears in a “best” list when your real problem is occasionally running out of ordinary ice. A freezer tray or purchased bag can remain the more practical choice for infrequent use.
Plan for one serving period, not a theoretical 24-hour run
Ask how much ice you want available together. For an illustrative gathering, suppose eight people each have two drinks and you allocate four ounces of ice per drink. That is 8 × 2 × 4 = 64 ounces, or four pounds. This is a planning example, not a recommended serving size or a performance test.
Four pounds is more than one full 1.3-pound or 2.6-pound basket. Making ice ahead and transferring it to a freezer therefore solves a different problem from choosing the quickest first batch. The useful question is whether your storage and preparation routine cover that serving period—not whether a specification says 26, 35, or 45 pounds per day.
Before a gathering: prepare a reserve rather than planning to serve everyone from the first few pieces. A daily maximum assumes continued production; it is not the amount waiting in the machine at any one moment.
Separate ice production from ice storage
Do not assume a countertop basket will keep finished ice frozen indefinitely. EUHOMY’s Tile Plus FAQ says the machine does not have a preservation function, and ecozy explicitly recommends freezer transfers. Treat collection capacity as temporary working space, not an alternative freezer compartment.
Think through the next step before buying: serving immediately, carrying the basket to a freezer container, or making a reserve ahead of visitors. An expanding basket, removable basket, and insulated enclosure address different parts of that routine. None automatically establishes how long the ice will retain its original texture.
Check the working footprint, not just the closed dimensions
Measure space for the appliance, opening the lid or door, removing the basket, and adding water. A carry handle can help reposition a machine; a pull-out tank can change where you refill it. Neither benefit is useful when the appliance has to be wedged against surrounding objects.
For example, the ecozy manual requires six inches of clearance on all sides. Check each model’s own requirement rather than borrowing one clearance rule for the whole shortlist. Where a listing and manual disagree about dimensions, confirm the offered unit before purchasing instead of choosing whichever measurement fits your counter.
Judge cleaning by access as well as the button
A self-cleaning label describes a feature, not the end of maintenance. EUHOMY’s Tile Plus guidance recommends cleaning weekly, removing detachable parts, and wiping internal surfaces. The IM039’s removable lid and ecozy’s pull-out tank offer different access arrangements worth examining before choosing.
Read the model’s instructions for the correct cleaner, rinsing, draining, and drying procedure. Do not transfer chemical concentrations from an unrelated manual just because another machine looks similar. A model-specific handbook is particularly important when retail pages mix several variants under one product family.
Keep water choice and running costs model-specific
Use the drinking water and preparation method specified for the exact appliance. EUHOMY’s Tile Plus FAQ recommends filtered water; its Pearl L1 Max guidance lists distilled, filtered, or bottled water. Those statements do not create one universal water requirement for every ice maker.
Similarly, rated wattage is not measured daily energy consumption. Without comparable operating measurements, I would not rank these machines by running cost or label one the energy-saving winner. Compare the delivered price and the features you will use, then consider cleaners, your water supply, and freezer storage as part of ownership.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which countertop ice maker would I start with for everyday drinks?
For ordinary bullet ice, I would start with the EUHOMY IM001-B because its handle, cleaning cycle, and documented compact footprint make a coherent everyday setup. Choose the IM039 for nugget ice or the IM-FP for square cubes instead. The recommendation changes with the desired ice format.
Does “ice in six minutes” mean a full basket?
No. The IM001-B and Silonn advertisements describe nine pieces in that time. The IM039’s five-to-seven-minute figure describes the start of nugget production. Neither is a full-basket promise, and the IM-FP’s advertised 24-piece batch is a different quantity again.
Will these machines keep ice frozen overnight?
I would not buy any of these selected configurations on that assumption. The reviewed documentation does not establish freezer-style overnight storage. EUHOMY and ecozy direct users toward transferring unused ice, and insulation alone should not be read as refrigerated ice storage.
Is nugget ice the same as bullet ice?
No. The IM039 and ecozy are specifically sold as nugget makers, while the IM001-B and SLIM33B make bullet ice. A choice of ice size is not the same as a choice of ice type. Match the machine to the texture and format you prefer rather than expecting a size setting to turn one type into another.
Can I use distilled water?
Check the exact model’s guidance. EUHOMY lists distilled water among the options for Pearl L1 Max; the instructions should determine suitability for another machine. My countertop water distiller comparison covers making distilled water at home, but a distiller is not a required accessory for every ice maker.
Can I make ice from juice or other drinks?
Do not assume these water-fed machines are suitable for other liquids. EUHOMY’s Tile Plus guidance excludes milk, beverages, and alcohol, while ecozy’s manual specifies water only. Flavor the drink separately rather than putting an unapproved liquid into the reservoir.
Which model is quietest?
I have not established that. The sources do not provide a common test setup for all six machines, and this comparison does not include my own sound measurements. Do not treat an isolated decibel claim or one buyer’s experience as a reliable quietest-model ranking.
Is an external water container included with the EUHOMY square-cube model?
It is not confirmed in the selected accessory list. The advertisement’s two refill methods should not be interpreted as a promise that every compatible container comes in the box. Confirm the offered bundle and the refill arrangement before ordering additional equipment.
Final Verdict
I would choose from this shortlist in two stages: first decide the ice format, then choose the handling features that fit the household routine. For everyday bullet ice, the EUHOMY IM001-B is my starting recommendation. Its carry handle, cleaning cycle, and documented footprint make a straightforward combination without asking you to buy features unrelated to the ice you want.
The Silonn SLIM33B is worth comparing when its expanding basket appeals; the Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK is the simple-control alternative with two ice-size settings. I would not decide among the everyday options using a small difference in advertised batch timing or half a pound of claimed daily production.
For square cubes, the EUHOMY IM-FP / Tile Plus has a distinct role thanks to thickness control and its larger stated basket. For nugget ice, I would begin with the IM039 / Pearl L1 Max and move to the ecozy IM-NS451B when the pull-out tank, app control, and display are features I would actually use.
Before ordering, check the exact configuration, available counter space, cleaning instructions, and included equipment. The most useful purchase is not automatically the highest-output model: it is the one that supplies your preferred ice within a refilling, cleaning, and storage routine you are willing to maintain.
Sources and Product Documents
Reviewed October 2, 2026. These links identify the listings and manufacturer documents used for the selected configurations. Published claims are not independent performance measurements.
- Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK selected black listing and Curtis/Frigidaire EFIC128_AMZ-BLACK catalog entry. Identity was cross-checked using UPC 058465832094. Reservoir and basket capacities follow that catalog entry; timing and included scoop/instructions follow the selected listing. EFIC117-SS and the differently suffixed EFIC128-BLACK-6COM manual were not used as exact-variant evidence. Conflicting dimension and power fields were omitted.
- EUHOMY IM001-B listing and ASIN-linked brand comparison chart. Only the appropriate product column was used for each configuration.
- Silonn selected expandable-basket listing and SLIM33B manufacturer specifications. Differing daily-output claims are retained as a limitation.
- EUHOMY square-cube listing, Tile Plus specifications and ownership FAQ, and EUHOMY model-support directory. Conflicting dimension fields were not used for a size ranking.
- EUHOMY IM039 selected bundle and Pearl L1 Max specifications and FAQ. A ZX-IM-12G manual returned during research was excluded.
- ecozy selected IM-NS451B listing, manufacturer product page, and IM-NS451B manual V1.03, including package contents, operating guidance, and the specification table.